Roof Replacement
in Madison, WI —
Done in a Day.
The only Madison roofing contractor with GAF Master Elite certification — meaning your replacement qualifies for the strongest warranty in the industry.
Full tear-off down to the deck. Complete decking inspection. New GAF installation with ice and water shield, synthetic underlayment, ridge vent, and all flashing. Permit pulled and filed. Cleanup done. Most Madison homes finished start to finish in a single day.
Free inspection · No obligation · Local Madison crew · We respond within 2 hours
Replace or Repair —
How to Know Which
One You Need.
This is the question most Madison homeowners start with. Here's an honest breakdown — because the right answer saves you money either way.
7 Steps from
First Call to
Finished Roof.
No surprises. No ambiguity. Here's exactly what happens when Buckshot replaces a roof on a Madison home — from the moment you call to the moment you hold your warranty certificate.
Free inspection and full written documentation
We come to your home at no cost. Our inspector photographs every facet of your roof — shingles, decking condition from the attic, pipe boot flashing, chimney step flashing, valley flashing, drip edge, gutters, ridge cap, and soffit ventilation. If storm damage is present, we document everything at the detail level needed for an insurance claim. You receive a written findings summary before we discuss pricing.
Line-item written estimate — no vague totals
Your estimate breaks out every cost individually: tear-off labor, disposal fees, estimated decking board replacement, ice and water shield footage, underlayment type and coverage, shingle product and color, ridge cap, pipe boot replacements, drip edge, chimney flashing if needed, and permit fees. No line items get added on installation day that weren't in the estimate.
Material selection and color consultation
As a GAF Master Elite contractor, we have access to the full GAF product line. We bring physical shingle samples to your home. We explain the warranty difference between Timberline HDZ, UHDZ, and premium options like Camelot II. We also show you how each color reads against your siding and trim in Wisconsin's natural light — colors look different on a sample card versus on an actual roof slope in Madison's climate.
Permit acquisition — every job, no exceptions
We pull every required permit through the City of Madison or Dane County before scheduling your installation. WI License DC-080900045. Homeowners who use contractors who skip permits face failed inspections, voided homeowner's insurance, and legal liability during resale. Every Buckshot replacement is fully permitted and passes final inspection.
Installation day — full replacement in a single day
Crew arrives 7–8 AM. Protective tarps go around the full perimeter. Magnetic nail sweepers are staged before tear-off begins. Old roofing system is completely removed, decking is inspected board by board — any rotted sections are replaced and photographed. Ice and water shield goes on every eave and valley. Synthetic underlayment covers the full deck. GAF shingles are installed to manufacturer specifications. Ridge vent installation is included on every replacement — proper ventilation is non-negotiable for GAF warranty validity in Wisconsin's climate.
Same-day cleanup — magnetic sweepers, two passes
All tear-off debris — old shingles, underlayment, nails, damaged decking — is loaded and removed in our truck before we leave. Magnetic nail sweepers make two full passes across your yard, driveway, and landscaped areas. We walk the property with you and address any questions on the spot. Your neighbor shouldn't even know we were there by the time we leave.
Permit inspection, warranty registration, and documentation package
The City of Madison or Dane County building inspector signs off on the completed installation. We register your GAF System Plus warranty in your name and provide your documentation package the same day: the warranty certificate, permit closeout, photo record of any decking replacements, and our written workmanship warranty. Everything you'd need for an insurance claim, a resale, or a future warranty claim is in that package.
Real Numbers.
By Home Size.
We give actual ranges based on real Dane County jobs — not the "$5,000–$50,000 it depends" non-answer. If your home falls outside these ranges, we'll tell you why during your free estimate.
| Home Type | Square Footage | Typical Cost Range | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small ranch or bungalow | 1,000–1,400 sq ft | $7,500 – $11,000 | Single-layer tear-off, standard pitch, GAF Timberline HDZ |
| Mid-size colonial or split-level | 1,400–2,000 sq ft | $11,000 – $15,500 | Most common size range in Madison; one-day completion typical |
| Large two-story home | 2,000–2,800 sq ft | $15,500 – $22,000 | Complex rooflines, multiple valleys, or premium shingle selection |
| Large or complex / steep pitch | 2,800+ sq ft | $22,000 – $35,000+ | Victorian, multiple dormers, steep slope, or Shorewood Hills / Maple Bluff homes |
All prices reflect GAF architectural shingles, full tear-off, Madison-area labor rates, permit fees, and standard complexity. Metal roofing runs 2–3x asphalt pricing.
What moves your number:
Insurance-funded replacement? If your replacement is being covered by a homeowner's claim, you pay only your deductible. Buckshot works directly with your adjuster to ensure full replacement cost value is recovered under your policy. Deductibles in Wisconsin typically run $1,000–$2,500 — the rest is handled between us and your insurer.
Which Shingle Is
Right for Your
Replacement?
The shingle you choose determines your roof's performance through Wisconsin winters, spring hail, and 30+ years of freeze-thaw cycles. Here's an honest breakdown of what we install and when each makes sense.
GAF Timberline HDZ
The most commonly installed architectural shingle in the country — for good reason. LayerLock Technology bonds the shadow band layer permanently, which improves wind resistance and eliminates the primary failure point of traditional shingles. For most Madison homes, it's the benchmark choice: strong performance, competitive cost, and full eligibility for the 50-year System Plus warranty when installed by a Master Elite contractor.
Algae resistance matters more than most homeowners realize — north-facing slopes in Madison's shade-heavy neighborhoods develop black streaking without it. StainGuard Plus addresses that without any additional treatment.
GAF Timberline UHDZ
Builds on the HDZ with deeper dimensional shadow lines and richer color variation. On a home with strong architectural character — dormers, multiple pitches, steep slope — the UHDZ looks dramatically better than standard architectural shingles. The cost premium runs approximately 15–20% over HDZ.
Worth considering if you're planning to sell within five years, or if you're in a Madison neighborhood like Westmorland, Vilas, or near the University where curb appeal has a direct effect on property value.
GAF Camelot II
A premium designer shingle that replicates the appearance of cedar shake without the maintenance. At 30% heavier than standard architectural shingles, it provides increased impact resistance — relevant for Madison's spring hail exposure. The visual effect is distinctive on homes with real architectural character.
Metal Roofing
Standing seam metal roofing costs 2–3x asphalt upfront, but the math changes when you factor in lifespan. A single metal roof can outlast two asphalt replacements. For Wisconsin specifically, metal sheds snow and ice naturally — which significantly reduces ice dam formation on homes that have had recurring problems despite good ventilation.
We install standing seam steel and Galvalume. We also install exposed fastener metal panels on outbuildings, garages, and secondary structures where cost matters more than aesthetics.
Wisconsin building code requires self-adhering ice and water shield at all roof eaves. We install it beyond the code minimum — at eaves, all valleys, around every chimney, skylight, pipe boot, and step flashing location. A roofer who doesn't include ice and water shield in a Wisconsin replacement quote is cutting corners. Period.
Most Hail Claims
Cover Full Replacement.
Here's Why That Matters.
A large percentage of Madison roof replacements are insurance-funded after hail or wind events. If your roof has storm damage, the process is more straightforward than most homeowners expect — especially with the right contractor involved.
Free inspection and professional damage documentation
We photograph every area of hail impact, measure hit density per square, and prepare a formal damage report formatted specifically for insurance submission — not just phone photos.
Claim filing support
We assist with the claim and ensure damage is reported within your policy's window. Wisconsin policies typically allow 12 months from the storm date — waiting costs you options.
Adjuster meeting — we attend and present our findings
We attend your adjuster's site visit and show our documentation directly. Adjusters missing items during a single walk-through is common. Having a contractor with documented scope on the roof already changes the conversation.
Claim approval and RCV vs. ACV
We walk you through the difference between Replacement Cost Value (full replacement cost) and Actual Cash Value (depreciated payout) — and explain what your specific policy actually pays.
You pay your deductible. We handle the rest.
Once approved, your deductible is your only out-of-pocket cost. Buckshot bills your insurance company directly for the replacement cost value. Final permit documentation goes to your insurer for file closeout.
What if my claim was denied?
Denial isn't the end. Buckshot helps homeowners file formal disputes, request re-inspections, and in many cases have previously denied claims approved on second review. Our membership in 5 preferred carrier programs — Contractor Connection, Nexus, Innovation, Sedgewick, and MSP — means we speak the same professional language as insurance adjusters.
After a hail event in Sun Prairie, a homeowner received an initial ACV settlement of $4,200 for repairs. After Buckshot attended the re-inspection with our full photo documentation, the claim was reopened and settled at $22,000 for a complete RCV roof replacement — covering the full cost minus the deductible.
Free Storm Inspection — (608) 909-9109The Strongest Warranty
in Residential Roofing.
Only Through Master Elite.
Most roofing warranties sound impressive until you read the fine print. Here's an honest comparison of what Buckshot's GAF Master Elite certification unlocks versus what a standard Madison contractor can offer.
| Warranty Type | What's Covered | Term | Prorated? | Transferable? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GAF System Plus Requires Master Elite contractor Best Available | Shingles + workmanship + weather damage (full roofing system) | 50 yr | No | Yes — once |
| Buckshot Workmanship Included on every Buckshot installation | Labor and installation defects — our work specifically | 10 yr | No | No |
| GAF Standard Shingle Any licensed contractor | Shingles only — no workmanship, no ridge cap, no underlayment | 30 yr | Yes | Limited |
| Competitor Average Non-Master Elite contractors | Varies — often vague, often not in writing | 5–10 yr | Often | Rarely |
The 50-year System Plus warranty is non-prorated — if a covered failure occurs in year 40, GAF pays the same as year 1. It's also transferable to one subsequent homeowner, which adds real documented value at resale. Full GAF certification details →
What Actually
Differentiates Us.
You've probably already looked at two or three Madison roofing companies. Here's what you should be comparing — specifically for a replacement, not just for any roofing job.
- GAF Master Elite — fewer than 2,000 contractors nationally. In the Madison metro, that narrows to a handful. This is the only path to the 50-year System Plus warranty. No other certification unlocks it — regardless of how many years a company has been in business.
- 47 years replacing Wisconsin roofs. We know what freeze-thaw cycling does to decking from below. We know the ice dam patterns specific to Madison's climate zone. That experience informs every decking board decision we make during tear-off.
- Zero subcontractors on any replacement. The person who estimated your roof is in contact with the same foreman who installs it. We don't broker jobs to crews we don't supervise. Every crew member on your roof is a Buckshot employee — not a day-labor crew sourced for the week.
- Full permit compliance, documented. Some contractors skip permits to save time and cut your cost. The legal and insurance risk lands on you, not them. We pull every required Madison and Dane County permit on every job. WI License DC-080900045.
- Most homes done in a single day. We staff our replacement crews specifically to complete most Madison residential jobs between arrival and cleanup in one day. You sleep under a new roof the same night we start.
- 5 insurance carrier programs. Contractor Connection, Nexus, Innovation, Sedgewick, and MSP. If your replacement is insurance-funded, our pre-approval through these programs and our documentation process is a real advantage in claim outcome.
They did a great job! We had a major hail storm and damaged everything. They replaced our roof, gutters, and all of our siding and our house looks brand new.
Several hailstorms damaged my roof and I asked my insurance company to inspect the damage. Then I screened several contractors, before I found Buckshot. I had Buckshot replace my roof. They did everything I needed and helped me coordinate the process with my insurance. We examined several shingle options and discussed these together. They were courteous, efficient and cleaned up everything. We were watertight again and ultimately decided to install a solar system on the new roof. Well Done Buckshot!!
After hail damage to our roof and siding Buckshot Contracting was in our neighborhood surveying all the damage done. They surveyed our damage and met with the insurance adjuster to verify all the damage done. They went over the paperwork with me and once the bank approved work began. The crew worked on our house on one of the hottest weekends and did a fantastic job. Very very pleased with the whole job from start to finish. Job well done!!
If you want a reliable and responsible contractor. Stop searching now. Jeremy has been so amazing with helping me get my house back together after the tornado. They do an amazing job and show up when they say they will be there. I'm looking forward to working with buckshot contractors on many more projects. Thanks for doing such an amazing job Buckshot.
Over the moon happy with Buckshot replacing hail damaged roof & siding on my house. Friendly, fast & competent. Super skilled carpenter did complicated reconstruction of a greenhouse sunporch roof. And they worked within my insurance coverage. My go-to for any future exterior work.
They helped with taking care of all repairs and anything else that I had questions about. I highly recommend them if you are planning to remodel or if you have storm damages. They do it all — roofing, gutters, siding, and garage door.
11 Questions
Before You Decide.
How much does a roof replacement cost in Madison WI?
How long does a roof replacement take in Madison?
Do I need a permit for a roof replacement in Madison WI?
How long does a GAF roof last in Wisconsin?
What is the best roofing shingle for Wisconsin winters?
Should I replace my roof or repair it?
Can I get a roof replacement in winter in Madison?
What happens to my old shingles and roofing materials?
Do you replace the decking during a roof replacement?
What is ice and water shield and do I need it in Wisconsin?
Will a new roof increase my home value in Madison?
Same-Day Emergency
Response Across
All of Dane County.
From our office at 621 N Sherman Ave in Madison, we complete roof replacements across the entire Dane County metro and surrounding communities. Whether you're near the Capitol Square, in the University area, on the east side, or in a suburb — our crew covers it with same-week scheduling.
| Community | ZIP | Avg Drive Time | Same-Day Emergency? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Madison (all neighborhoods)Primary | 53703–53718 | Home base | Yes |
| Sun Prairie | 53590 | 15 min east | Yes |
| Middleton | 53562 | 12 min west | Yes |
| Fitchburg | 53711 | 10 min south | Yes |
| Verona | 53593 | 20 min SW | Yes |
| Waunakee | 53597 | 18 min north | Yes |
| Stoughton | 53589 | 25 min SE | Yes |
| DeForest | 53532 | 22 min north | Yes |
| McFarland | 53558 | 15 min SE | Yes |
| Oregon | 53575 | 20 min south | Yes |
621 N Sherman Ave B5, Madison WI 53704 · Mon–Fri 8AM–5PM · Sat 8AM–5PM · (608) 909-9109 · 24/7 Emergency
More From Buckshot
Across Wisconsin & Iowa.
Madison Pages
Other Wisconsin Locations
Madison Roof Replacement.
Done Right, Done in a Day.
GAF Master Elite certified · 50-year warranty available · Free inspection · No subcontractors ever.
621 N Sherman Ave B5, Madison WI 53704 · Mon–Fri 8AM–5PM · Sat 8AM–5PM · 24/7 Emergency
WI Lic. DC-080900045 · GAF Master Elite Certified · Family-Owned Since 1979