Fiber cement: the last siding your home needs.
It costs more than vinyl up front, but in Wisconsin's climate it often makes more sense long-term. Fiber cement, including James Hardie style board, doesn't crack in freeze-thaw, holds paint 15-plus years, resists hail, fire, and woodpeckers, and lasts 30 to 50 years. If you're replacing storm-damaged siding for the second time, this is the conversation to have.
Got it. We'll be in touch.
Thanks, there. We received your siding estimate request and respond within 2 hours during business hours.
Built for the climate that wears siding out.
Wisconsin's freeze-thaw cycles, UV, hail, and even woodpeckers are what shorten a siding's life. Fiber cement is engineered against every one of them.
No freeze-thaw cracking
Unlike vinyl, fiber cement does not crack in freeze-thaw cycles. It holds its shape and seal through every Wisconsin winter.
Impact resistant
Hailstones that dent vinyl panels typically don't penetrate fiber cement. It shrugs off most hail that would total a vinyl wall.
Fire resistant
Fiber cement is fire resistant, a real advantage over both vinyl and wood, and one insurers and buyers value.
No woodpecker damage
It doesn't attract woodpeckers, a genuine issue with wood siding in parts of Wisconsin where woodpecker activity is high.
Holds paint 15+ years
It takes and holds paint for 15-plus years, far longer than wood, so repaint cycles are rare and color stays crisp.
30 to 50 year life
In the same climate where vinyl lasts 20 to 25 years, fiber cement runs 30 to 50 years with periodic repainting.
James Hardie set the category.
James Hardie is the name most associated with fiber cement, the brand that defined the category and engineered it specifically for climate zones like ours. When homeowners ask us for "Hardie board," this is the product class they mean.
- Climate-engineered boards formulated for cold, wet, freeze-thaw regions like Wisconsin
- Lap, panel, and shake styles that mimic wood and cedar without the upkeep
- Baked-in color options plus paintable boards that hold finish for years
- Trim and accent pieces for a fully finished, architectural look
We install fiber cement siding including James Hardie style board. Ask about current product availability and color lines during your free estimate.
When fiber cement is worth the extra.
It's not the right answer for every home. We'd rather tell you the truth than sell you up. Here's the honest line, and we confirm it at your free estimate.
These point to the upgrade
- You've had repeated hail events and are replacing storm-damaged siding a second time.
- You're a long-term owner and want the lowest lifetime maintenance cost.
- Your home is higher-end and the premium look adds resale value.
- You want fire resistance or have woodpecker problems with wood siding.
- You're done thinking about siding and want it to outlast you in the home.
These point back to vinyl
- You're on a standard residential budget and need the lowest installed cost.
- You plan to sell within a few years and won't recoup the premium.
- You want zero repainting, ever, vinyl's color is in the material.
- Your area sees little hail and freeze-thaw is your main concern.
What fiber cement costs.
Real ranges from actual Wisconsin jobs. It costs more than vinyl up front; the value is in the decades it adds. On-site estimates are free and specific to your home.
The honest side-by-side.
The comparison every first-time replacer wants. We'll walk you through both at your free estimate, with no pressure in either direction.
| Factor | Fiber Cement | Vinyl Siding |
|---|---|---|
| Installed cost | $10–$18 / sq ft | $7–$12 / sq ft |
| Lifespan in WI | 30–50 years | 20–25 years |
| Hail resistance | Impact resistant | Dents at ½", cracks at 1" |
| Freeze-thaw | Does not crack | Can crack if struck in extreme cold |
| Painting | Holds paint 15+ years | Never, color is in the material |
| Fire resistance | Fire resistant | Not rated |
| Best for | Long-term owners, repeated hail, higher-end homes | Most standard residential budgets |
A storm claim can be your chance to upgrade.
Hail that damaged your roof almost always damaged your siding too. Those panels are covered under most homeowner's policies, but only if the claim is documented properly. We inspect and photograph all siding damage, include it in the same adjuster scope as any roof damage, and advocate for the full approved scope. Same process as our roofing: you pay your deductible, we handle the rest, and many homeowners use that moment to step up to fiber cement.
- Document & photograph all siding damage
- Combine siding + roof in one claim
- Attend the adjuster meeting with you
- Advocate for the full approved scope
- You pay the deductible, we bill the rest
Spread the upgrade over manageable payments.
Fiber cement is a long-term investment, and you don't have to pay it all at once. Through Service Finance Company we offer payment plans, including 0% promotional options, so the better material is within reach. Checking your rate won't affect your credit.
4.9 stars across 80 verified reviews.
Their professionalism and attention to detail were evident. The new siding looks amazing and gave the building a fresh, modern look that we're proud of.
Buckshot was top notch. They helped me deal with everything at ease, all I had to do was pick out my colors and they handled the rest.
Thanks so much for everything you have done so that our house is done right. The world needs more people like you.
Frequently asked questions.
Q.01Is fiber cement worth it over vinyl in Wisconsin?+
Q.02What is James Hardie siding?+
Q.03How much does fiber cement siding cost?+
Q.04Does fiber cement hold up to hail?+
Q.05Does fiber cement need painting?+
Q.06Does insurance cover replacing siding with fiber cement?+
More from Buckshot.
The siding you install once.
Free on-site estimate, an honest fiber-cement-vs-vinyl recommendation, samples brought to your home, and financing if you need it. Family-owned since 1979, WI Lic. DC-080900045, across Wisconsin and Iowa.