FAMILY-OWNED · SINCE 1979 MADISON, WI · CENTERVILLE, IA LIC. DC-080900045
24/7 STORM LINE (608) 909-9109
Stoughton, WI · Dane County · Since 1979

Roofing for Stoughton's historic homes and open-country storms.

Stoughton's older neighborhoods are full of Victorian and early 1900s homes with steep pitches, turrets, dormers, and tall brick chimneys, and every one of those details is a place water can get in. Add wind sweeping in off open Dane County farmland, and roofs here need careful flashing as much as good shingles. Our Buckshot team inspects your roof, documents storm damage for your insurer, and handles repairs, full replacement, siding, and seamless gutters with our own GAF Master Elite crews.

GAF Master Elite FORTIFIED Provider BBB A+ · 47 Years
Serving Stoughton & all of Dane County(608) 909-9109WI Lic. DC-080900045

Free Stoughton roof inspection

Flashing, leak and storm check with photos. Free.

    Got it. We will call you.

    A Buckshot project manager will reach out shortly to set your free inspection. Storm emergency? Call (608) 909-9109 now.

    1979

    Family-owned, est.

    5

    Insurance programs we work with

    1 day

    Typical install

    4.7

    Homeowner rating

    What we do in Stoughton

    Complex rooflines, flashed the right way.

    An older Stoughton roof usually leaks where two planes meet, around a turret, a dormer wall, or a chimney that has settled over a century. Buckshot finds those spots and handles the whole exterior, including GAF shingle or standing seam metal roofs, fiber cement and vinyl siding, and seamless gutters, handled by one Buckshot crew start to finish.

    Wind damage?

    When a storm tears across open farmland.

    Stoughton sits in open country southeast of Madison, and storms crossing the fields reach town at full strength. The town has seen what a tornado can do, but most claims here come from quieter damage, like shingles lifted along a ridge or flashing pried loose at a chimney. Buckshot climbs up, documents it, and prepares the claim, so when coverage applies your cost is typically the deductible. Start with a free Stoughton inspection.

    01

    Roof and attic walk-through

    Every slope, every chimney, and the underside of the roof deck gets photographed, so the record of storm damage is complete.

    02

    Evidence to your carrier

    We assemble photos, measurements, and a line-item scope and help you file with your insurer.

    03

    Inspection day with the adjuster

    Complex roofs hide damage on back slopes and behind turrets. We make sure the adjuster sees all of it.

    04

    Final invoice, final payment

    After we finish, the completed-work invoice goes to your carrier so the withheld depreciation can be released.

    How an insurer pays for a Stoughton roof

    ACV

    Actual Cash Value

    The value of your existing roof once its age is factored in. Carriers normally pay this portion first.

    RCV

    Replacement Cost Value

    What an equivalent new roof would cost. The remaining balance usually comes once the work is finished.

    Carrier and TPA programs Buckshot is enrolled in

    Contractor ConnectionNexusInnovationSedgwickMSP

    Why Stoughton hires Buckshot

    A roofer that understands older homes.

    Plenty of crews can shingle a simple ranch. Fewer know how to flash a turret or tie a new roof into a century-old chimney without leaks. Buckshot has worked on south-central Wisconsin homes since 1979, just up the road in Madison, with our own crews and a warranty we stand behind.

    • GAF Master Elite certified. Only about 2% of roofers earn it from GAF, and it is what makes the 50-year System Plus warranty available to you.
    • Claims handled in person. We work within five carrier programs and meet your adjuster at the house.
    • In-house crews. Your estimator, installer, and warranty contact all work for Buckshot.
    • Credentials on record. FORTIFIED, BBB A+, NRCA, WRCA, UASRC, InterNACHI, IICRC, and WI license DC-080900045.
    Buckshot General Contracting roofing crew on a completed south-central Wisconsin home
    Serving Stoughton · Dane County, WI

    Honest pricing

    Why an older Stoughton roof costs more to do right.

    Stoughton reroofs generally cost $8,500 to $18,000, and a simple 1,800 square foot ranch often lands between $12,000 and $15,000 with GAF Timberline HDZ. Steep Victorian pitches, turrets, and extra chimneys push a job toward the top of the range because they take more flashing, safety setup, and labor. Covered storm claims usually come down to your deductible, every estimate is itemized, and Service Finance Company offers 0% financing.
    Insured storm damage
    Your deductible
    When the carrier approves the claim.
    Stoughton price range
    $8,500 to $18,000
    Paying without a claim.
    Simple 1,800 sq ft ranch
    $12,000 to $15,000
    GAF Timberline HDZ, one day for most.
    Roof squaresSteepness of the roofLayers to removeDecking conditionVentilationTurrets, dormers & chimneysShingle line

    Warranty, in plain terms

    A warranty that fits a century-old house.

    Master Elite certification lets Buckshot register the 50-year System Plus warranty on a qualifying GAF roof system, including steep, detailed Stoughton roofs, when the shingles are installed with the required GAF accessories. It turns a new roof on an old house into a documented, long-term investment. Contractors outside the program are limited to GAF's standard prorated coverage.
    WarrantyWhat it coversTermWho can register it
    GAF System PlusBestShingles plus GAF accessories50 yrs, non-proratedMaster Elite contractors
    GAF StandardManufacturing defects30 yrs, proratedMost contractors
    Buckshot WorkmanshipOur installation laborIn writingBuckshot
    Storm-chaser defaultLittle or nothing after they leaveNoneOut-of-area crews

    Is your old roof letting water in?

    One visit tells you. We check every valley, turret, and chimney, then share the photos and our honest take on whether it needs an insurance claim, a repair, or just monitoring.

    GAF Master Elite$0 storm checkDetailed flashing workOwn crews

    Schedule my roof check

    A Dane County project manager will follow up with you.

      Got it. We will call you.

      A Buckshot project manager will reach out shortly to set your free inspection.

      WHAT GOES ON THE ROOF

      On a steep old roof, the details underneath matter most.

      A steep Stoughton roof sheds snow and rain quickly, but only if the layers under the shingles are built for it. Here is what we put down.

      • Impact-rated Class 4 options are an option for homes on open lots where hail and wind hit hardest, carrying the top UL 2218 impact rating.
      • GAF Timberline HDZ & UHDZ with a LayerLock nailing strip that holds shingles tight on tall, wind-exposed slopes.
      • Ice barrier in every valley, synthetic underlayment, and custom-fit flashing around turrets, dormers, and chimneys.
      • Deck check at tear-off because century-old board decking often hides rot, and we replace it before shingles go on.
      Roof decking inspection and ice and water shield during a Wisconsin roof replacementFull tear-off · valley ice barrier

      Standard shingles vs Class 4 in Stoughton

      Class 4 shingles suit Stoughton homes at the open edges of town, or any home whose insurer offers a meaningful discount. They absorb hail far better than standard shingles. Premium credits vary by carrier, so get the number from your agent, and we will quote each option separately.
      FactorStandard architecturalClass 4 impact-resistant
      Impact ratingUnder Class 4UL 2218 Class 4
      Hail impact resistanceFairVery high
      Possible insurance creditNot usuallyPossible, depends on your carrier
      Added costBaselineApproximately 10 to 20% added
      Best forIn-town lots with mature treesFarm-edge and hilltop homes

      REPAIR OR REPLACE

      Reflash the chimney, or reroof the house?

      Look at the flashing before the shingles. On older Stoughton homes a leak is often a flashing failure at a chimney, dormer, or turret, not a worn-out roof. If the shingles still lie flat and hold their granules, rebuilding that flashing is usually enough. If the shingles are curling or brittle, the roof has more than one layer, or it is close to twenty years old, replacement is the better investment and easier to support on a claim. We put the recommendation in writing, photos attached.
      Lean toward repairFlashing problem
      • Leak traced to a chimney, dormer, or turret
      • Shingles under about 15 years old
      • Only one layer on the roof
      • Shingles flat, granules intact
      • Board decking solid around the leak
      Lean toward replacementRoof-wide wear
      • Curling or brittle shingles on most slopes
      • Roof near 20 years old
      • Two layers already on the house
      • Rotted boards at eaves or valleys
      • A new 50-year GAF warranty appeals to you

      What time and storms do to an older Stoughton roof

      Loose chimney flashing

      Mortar joints wear and counter flashing pulls free, letting water run down inside the chimney.

      Leaks at dormer walls

      Siding and step flashing meet at dormer walls, a classic entry point on early 1900s homes.

      Ice in the valleys

      Deep valleys on complex roofs hold snow, and meltwater backs up under the shingles.

      Lifted ridge shingles

      Wind across open fields catches the ridge and hips first.

      Curling, brittle shingles

      Heat trapped in a poorly vented attic shortens shingle life from underneath.

      Stains near turrets and bays

      Curved and angled roof sections are hard to flash and often leak first.

      Our Stoughton area

      Rooted on the Yahara River.

      From the historic homes near downtown to newer houses in Kettle Park West and Nordic Ridge, Buckshot roofs all of Stoughton. We also work in Madison, McFarland, Oregon, Cottage Grove, Edgerton, Cambridge, Dunkirk, Pleasant Springs, Deerfield, and Fitchburg.

      Stoughton grew up along the Yahara River, and its Norwegian heritage shows in a downtown and older neighborhoods full of steep, detailed roofs. Those roofs face open-country wind, summer hail, and hard freeze-thaw winters. Every Buckshot reroof here includes valley ice barrier, flashing built for the home's details, and attic venting that holds the deck at outdoor temperature in winter.

      Stoughton neighborhoods

      Kettle Park WestNordic RidgeVirgin LakeMandt ParkKettle ParkRiverviewRacetrack ParkNorse ParkVennevoll

      Dane County & nearby

      MadisonMcFarlandOregonCottage GroveEdgertonCambridgeDunkirkPleasant SpringsDeerfieldFitchburg
      ZIP codes we cover include 53589, 53558, 53575, and nearby Dane County routes.
      Stoughton's roof problem

      Old roofs, open-country storms.

      Many Stoughton homes were built long before modern flashing and ventilation, and storms rolling across the open fields find every weak detail.

      Winter then packs ice into deep valleys and along cold eaves. We answer with rebuilt flashing, valley ice barrier, and balanced attic airflow.

      18-22
      Typical shingle lifespan, years
      UL 2218
      Highest impact rating
      608
      Local area code

      Roof leaking in Stoughton?

      Storm opened up your Stoughton roof? Call now.

      A limb through the roof, shingles stripped off a ridge, or water running down a chimney wall. You reach a person, and our crew can cover the opening and photograph the damage before more water gets in.

      Customer reviews

      Hear it from Buckshot homeowners.

      Posted on Google Google
      Joy I profile picture
      Joy I
      Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
      When the big storms came through the Madison-area in April 2026, I immediately started looking for a reputable roofer—who also understood the importance of weather-resistant materials that can withstand hail and wind. It didn’t take me long to find Brad from BCG. We had damage that needed to be repaired before the next round of storms came through later that day and Brad had a crew out within hours. Our neighbors also had damage, and when their roofing company didn’t show up, Brad and his crew also took on fixing their damage on the spot. The contracting process was done over email and we were able to clearly understand all of the options available to us. On the day of install, the crew was efficient and fast with their work. But also, mistakes can happen. And what matters to us is not that there’s perfection (because that’s not realistic), but how a contractor deals with a mistake. As they were taking down the tarps when they were finished with the roof, one of our lights next to the garage broke. Brad helped find a replacement online and had it shipped directly to our house! Such great service! All in all, we were very happy with Brad and the service we received from him and BCG. We’ve since recommended their services to several of our friends and neighbors who also had storm damage. While I hope we won’t have to do that again for a long time, we would work with BCG again in a heartbeat!
      Posted on Google Google
      Shelly Ziegler profile picture
      Shelly Ziegler
      Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
      I am extremely pleased with the service Matt Walmer from Buckshot General Contracting (BGC) provided for me during the hailstorm damage in Madison in April. I had just switched insurance companies one year ago and was worried about how much they would cover. Matt assured me everything would be taken care of and had nothing to worry about. True to his word he immediately answered phone calls during off hours even when he was with daughter at volleyball and answering texts in seconds Matt met up with assessor and arrived 20 minutes early. During roof replacement he stopped in 3 times to check the progress and next day he came back to do a walk around to make sure the cleanup was to his standards. I have been so blessed to work with Matt at BGC as my contractor as everything went so smoothly. No problems with my insurance company and I was the first one on my block to get my roof done. I also was telling Matt about some of my neighbors having problems with their insurance and he was willing to look at their paperwork and giving them advice on how to deal with them. I can proudly say I announced to them how good Matt was and gave them his card. Thank you so much Matt for your excellent service and being a great representative for Buckshot General Contracting. These days days it’s hard to find a business that is 100% committed to making sure the customer is their #1 concern. Going to be doing more work and sticking with them as I know it will be top quality.
      Posted on Google Google
      Amy Stephens profile picture
      Amy Stephens
      Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
      We contacted BGC after storm damage and had them completely re-roof and re-side our house, garage, and shed. The entire process was incredibly smooth from start to finish. They were easy to work with, handled all the details, and made what could have been a stressful situation completely worry-free. Our contact, Jayce Kirkland, was outstanding. His professionalism, communication, and courteous demeanor were truly a breath of fresh air. He took care of everything for us and made sure the project stayed on track every step of the way. We couldn’t be happier with the experience and have and would highly recommend BGC to anyone needing roofing or siding work!
      Posted on Google Google
      Rob Anast profile picture
      Rob Anast
      Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
      Very customer focused company. Replaced my roof and siding after hail and wind damage 6 years ago. Second hail and damage storm this year and they are my vendor of choice again. In process now to replace my roof and siding.
      Posted on Google Google
      paolo masone profile picture
      paolo masone
      Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
      Brad gave me a good price and the roof looks great! The roof was replaced in one day.
      Posted on Google Google
      Doug Cooper profile picture
      Doug Cooper
      Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
      They did an excellent job! Fast, efficient and did a great job cleaning up.
      Posted on Google Google
      christos karampetsos profile picture
      christos karampetsos
      Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
      My family member needed a roof replacement after the recent storm in Madison , Chad came out to inspect the roof and went over the options with us. Full roof replacement and the new roof looks GREAT, they were done with in 2 days and left no mess behind which was very thankful for. Thanks !!
      Posted on Google Google
      Jason Montez profile picture
      Jason Montez
      Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
      *update* number 2 I have been through about 4 different people now to get my issue fixed. They came and fixed the side that was leaking. The contractor that came out confirmed the siding wasnt installed properly and put in some flashing to fix the issue. Since it wasnt installed right i wanted the rest of the house done to prevent other issues and the company agreed to do that. Still not done and now im dealing with yet another person who has not contacted me to resolve my issue. Told them when this job was completed i wanted a new patio door as well to get the last year of the energy credit. Crickets. I have been very patient, but am beyond frustrated at this point. *update* After posting i was contacted regarding my review. Turns out the reason i wasn’t contacted was because my salesman is no longer with the company and never responded to tell me that when i called him (his number was still correct at the time of the call). I had a rep come to my home and immediately discuss solutions to the issue. Everything was done properly on my home, its just one of those things no one could foresee. I am beyond happy with the speed things are moving once i was contacted. Already making plans for additional work needed next season. Had windows and siding done. The windows crew was fantastic. Personable as well as professional. Siding crew was also great. My issue comes with the after care. My basement was leaking during rains. It also leaked running the sprinkler for new grass. Contacted my salesman and never heard back. Been probably a month? Had a contractor friend of mine come look and the issue was the siding wasnt ran low enough (or a piece of flashing would have worked as well) to stop water from coming through the basement from under the sill plate. Id have even paid to have it corrected, but no call. My issue is a simple one, but the aftercare deserves a one. The total score is because their crews were great. The people in admin simply need to be better. I had to remove foam that was trafficking water in and will be using flex seal to create a barrier since no call was made back. Update as of april, 2026. After some frustrating back and forth one of their contractors came our and looked at my situation late summer of 2025. Confirmed the siding wasnt done properly and installed flashing where the leak was and i haven’t had an issue since. Despite the numerous tornados weve had. With that said, Fall of 2025 i told them (after being informed the siding wasn’t done properly by their guy) i told them while the basement no longer seems to leak, i want the rest of the house covered with that flashing incase their are other problems. i dont want to refinish my basement to discover issues. The “salesman” essentially accused me of only wanting free things and after him explaining to me how awesome he was and that i was wrong, i stopped the phone call. The subcontractors they hire are overall solid, but some of the staff have made the company unusable for me. Just be cautious if you use them. Communication is great… until they get your money.
      Contact

      A short drive from Stoughton.

      Buckshot General Contracting
      Service area
      Stoughton & all of Dane County621 N Sherman Ave, Suite B5, Madison, WI 53704 (HQ)
      Hours
      Mon to Sat 8AM to 5PMEmergency storm line 24/7
      Credentials
      GAF Master EliteWI Lic. DC-080900045 · BBB A+ · FORTIFIED
      Stoughton roof questions

      Older homes, storms & Stoughton roofs.

      Want to talk it through?

      Call the Dane County team.

      Our Stoughton project managers, Ryan, Jayce, Jeremy, and Chad, are happy to answer questions by phone.

      Call (608) 909-9109

      Q.01Why does my old Stoughton house leak around the chimney?
      Chimneys on older homes settle and their mortar wears, so the counter flashing set into the brick loosens over time. Caulk only buys a season. The lasting fix is new step and counter flashing, sometimes with a cricket behind a wide chimney to split the water.
      Q.02Will insurance pay for storm damage on an older roof?
      If a covered storm caused the damage, age alone usually does not rule out a claim, though some policies pay older roofs on an actual cash value basis. Check your declarations page or ask your agent. We document the damage so your adjuster can separate storm damage from normal wear.
      Q.03Which neighborhoods and nearby towns do you serve?
      All of Stoughton, from the older blocks near downtown and the Yahara to Kettle Park West, Nordic Ridge, Virgin Lake, and Norse Park, plus Madison, McFarland, Oregon, Cottage Grove, Edgerton, Cambridge, Dunkirk, Pleasant Springs, Deerfield, and Fitchburg. Our Madison headquarters is about twenty minutes away.
      Q.04Are Class 4 shingles a good fit for Stoughton?
      For homes on open lots at the edge of town, often yes, since hail and wind reach them unbroken. In-town homes sheltered by mature trees may not need them. Some insurers discount premiums for UL 2218 Class 4 roofs, so ask yours before deciding.
      Q.05What does GAF Master Elite certification mean for my house?
      GAF limits it to around 2% of roofing contractors, based on licensing, insurance, and track record, and it is required to register the 50-year System Plus warranty. You can verify any roofer on GAF's website.
      Q.06What will a Stoughton reroof cost me?
      Most reroofs here run $8,500 to $18,000. A straightforward 1,800 square foot ranch is often $12,000 to $15,000 in GAF Timberline HDZ, while steep, detailed Victorian roofs cost more. Financing at 0% is available through Service Finance Company, and every estimate is itemized.
      Q.07Can you fix one leak without replacing the whole roof?
      Yes, as long as the remaining shingles are in good shape. Most leaks on older Stoughton homes start at flashing, and rebuilding it costs far less than a new roof. If the shingles themselves are failing, we will tell you so and show you why.
      Q.08How soon can you come out after a storm?
      Someone answers (608) 909-9109 at any hour. We deal with active leaks first, with temporary cover and photos, and schedule the full inspection once it is safe to get on the roof.
      Q.09Can you match siding and trim on an older home?
      We match siding profiles and colors as closely as today's products allow, and when an exact match is not possible we suggest redoing a full wall so it looks right. Choices include fiber cement or vinyl, along with seamless gutters sized for tall roofs.
      Q.10How long does a reroof take on a Victorian home?
      Simple roofs usually take one day. Steep or detailed Victorian roofs take longer, depending on pitch, layers, and flashing work. We protect landscaping, strip to the boards, replace rotted decking, and sweep the property with magnets when we finish.

      Book a roof and flashing check in Stoughton.

      We go over every slope, valley, and chimney, photograph what we find, and give you an honest read on claim, repair, or wait. GAF Master Elite, family-owned since 1979.

      Buckshot General Contracting (BGC) · 621 N Sherman Ave, Suite B5, Madison, WI 53704 · serving Stoughton and all of Dane County · WI Lic. DC-080900045 · GAF Master Elite Certified · Family-Owned Since 1979 · Mon to Sat 8AM to 5PM, Emergency 24/7 · (608) 909-9109. Pricing ranges are estimates and vary by roof size, pitch, access, material selection, and decking condition; your written estimate governs. Insurance coverage, deductibles, ACV and RCV settlements, recoverable depreciation, and any impact-resistant-shingle premium credit are determined solely by your carrier and policy; we do not guarantee any claim outcome or discount. Material lifespans are typical ranges for the local climate, not warranties. Advice here about repairing versus replacing is general and does not determine coverage. Financing provided through Service Finance Company, LLC, subject to credit approval. GAF System Plus and manufacturer warranty terms are governed by GAF's published documents and require a registered, qualifying installation.

      Crew available todayFreeInspection1 dayMost installsDeductible onlyOn covered claims4.9 / 5200+ Google reviews

      ●  From the crew that writes the guides

      Done reading? Let us look for you.

      The guides tell you what to check from the ground. We get on the ladder, photograph every facet, and tell you straight: a claim, a repair, or nothing to worry about.

      Free roof inspection

      Three fields. Twenty minutes on site. Zero cost, zero obligation.

      Free · No obligation · No spam

      Rather talk? (608) 909-9109