Madison's Local Roof Replacement Crew
Family-owned in Madison since 1979, replacing roofs across Dane County, from Middleton to Sun Prairie to Verona. Local crews who know our winters, GAF Master Elite quality, and a 50-year System Plus warranty. Free on-site estimate.
Free Replacement Quote
Got it. We'll be in touch.
We received your replacement request and respond within 2 hours during business hours. For an active leak, call (608) 909-9109.
First, Do You Even Need a Replacement?
This is where most Madison homeowners start, and the honest answer saves you money either way. We tell people to repair when that is the right call. Here is how to tell.
These signs point to a full new roof
- Roof is 18+ years old, repeated repairs cost more than replacement in this climate.
- Heavy granule loss in the gutters.
- Sagging or spongy decking.
- Two shingle layers already installed (code caps roofs at two).
- Damage across multiple roof facets from hail or wind.
- Rising energy bills from a roof that no longer ventilates properly.
These situations don't need a full replacement
- Roof is under 12 years old and damage is limited to one section.
- A single shingle or small patch blew off and the rest is sound.
- Flashing failure at one chimney, skylight, or pipe boot.
- A leak traced to a single penetration that can be sealed.
- Ice dam damage at one eave that targeted repair can solve.
7 Steps From First Call to Finished Roof
Free inspection & written findings
We photograph every facet, shingles, decking from the attic, flashing, gutters, and ventilation, and give you a written summary before we discuss price.
Line-item estimate
Every cost broken out: tear-off, disposal, decking, ice and water shield, underlayment, shingle, ridge cap, flashing, and permit. Nothing added on install day.
Material & color consult
Physical GAF samples at your home. We explain the warranty difference between tiers and show how colors read in real Midwest light.
Permit pulled, every job
We pull every required permit before scheduling. WI License DC-080900045. Skipping permits voids insurance and creates resale liability.
Install day, one day
Crew arrives 7 to 8 AM, perimeter tarped. Full tear-off, board-by-board decking check, ice and water shield, underlayment, GAF shingles, ridge vent included.
Same-day cleanup
All debris hauled out in our truck. Magnetic nail sweepers make two full passes, and we walk the property with you before we leave.
Inspection & warranty
The building inspector signs off. We register your GAF System Plus warranty and hand you the full documentation package the same day.
We replace what's under the shingles too.
After tear-off, every decking board is inspected and any rotted section is replaced and photographed before new material goes down. Ice and water shield goes on beyond code minimum, at all eaves, every valley, and around every chimney, skylight, and pipe boot.
What a Madison Replacement Costs
Real ranges by home size, not the "it depends" non-answer. If your home falls outside these, we tell you why during your free estimate.
| Home type | Size | Typical range | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small ranch / bungalow | 1,000–1,400 sq ft | $7,500 to $11,000 | Single-layer tear-off, standard pitch, GAF Timberline HDZ |
| Mid-size colonial / split | 1,400–2,000 sq ft | $11,000 to $15,500 | Most common size, one-day completion typical |
| Large two-story | 2,000–2,800 sq ft | $15,500 to $22,000 | Complex rooflines, multiple valleys, or premium shingle |
| Large / complex / steep | 2,800+ sq ft | $22,000 to $35,000+ | Multiple dormers, steep slope, designer or metal options |
Insurance-funded replacement? If a homeowner's claim is covering it, you pay only your deductible, typically $1,000 to $2,500 in Wisconsin, and Buckshot bills your insurer directly for the full replacement cost. All ranges reflect GAF architectural shingles, full tear-off, regional labor, and permit fees. Metal roofing runs 2 to 3x asphalt pricing.
Which Shingle Is Right for Your Replacement?
GAF Timberline HDZ
The benchmark architectural shingle.
- Up to 130 mph wind resistance
- StainGuard Plus algae resistance
- 50-yr System Plus eligible
- Best for most homes
GAF Timberline UHDZ
Deeper shadow lines, richer color.
- Ultra high-def shadow depth
- All HDZ warranties & ratings
- About 15 to 20% over HDZ
- Best for higher-value homes
GAF Camelot II
Cedar-shake look, no maintenance.
- 30% heavier, impact resistant
- Distinctive on character homes
- Strong hail performance
- Best for premium curb appeal
Metal Roofing
Standing seam steel & Galvalume.
- 40 to 70 year lifespan
- Naturally sheds snow & ice
- Reduces ice dams
- Best for long-term owners
Most Hail Claims Cover Full Replacement
We photograph every hail impact, measure hit density, and prepare a formal report formatted for insurance, then attend the adjuster meeting and present our findings. Adjusters miss damage on a single walk-through, a documented contractor on the roof changes the conversation. You pay only your deductible, we bill your insurer for the rest.
An initial ACV settlement of $4,200 for repairs was reopened after Buckshot attended the re-inspection with full photo documentation, and settled at $22,000 for a complete replacement, covered minus the deductible.
The Strongest Warranty in Residential Roofing
Most warranties sound impressive until you read the fine print. Here is what GAF Master Elite unlocks versus what a standard contractor can offer.
| Warranty | Covers | Term | Prorated | Transferable |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GAF System Plus (Master Elite) | Shingles + workmanship + weather (full system) | 50 yr | No | Yes, once |
| Buckshot Workmanship | Labor & installation defects | 10 yr | No | No |
| GAF Standard Shingle | Shingles only, no workmanship | 30 yr | Yes | Limited |
| Competitor average | Varies, often vague, often not in writing | 5–10 yr | Often | Rarely |
The 50-year System Plus warranty is non-prorated: a covered failure in year 40 pays the same as year 1, and it transfers to one future owner, which adds documented value at resale.
What Actually Differentiates Us
GAF Master Elite
Fewer than 2% of US contractors qualify. It is the only path to the 50-year System Plus warranty, no other certification unlocks it.
Zero subcontractors
Every crew member is a Buckshot employee. The person who estimates your roof is in contact with the foreman who installs it.
47 years in this climate
We know what freeze-thaw does to decking from below and the ice-dam patterns specific to the Midwest. That informs every decking decision.
Full permit compliance
We pull every required permit on every job, documented. WI License DC-080900045. Skipping them puts the legal and insurance risk on you.
Most homes in one day
We staff replacement crews to finish most homes from arrival to cleanup in a single day. You sleep under a new roof the night we start.
5 insurance carrier programs
Contractor Connection, Nexus, Innovation, Sedgwick, and MSP. Pre-approval and our documentation are a real advantage in claim outcomes.
4.9 Stars Across 80 Verified Reviews
"We had a major hail storm. They replaced our roof, gutters, and all of our siding and our house looks brand new."
"They helped coordinate the whole process with my insurance. Courteous, efficient, and cleaned up everything. Well done Buckshot."
"You could not even tell they had been there, except that I had a new roof. I didn't even find a nail."
Madison-Area Roofs We've Replaced
Questions Before You Decide
Ready for a quote?
Free inspection, written line-item estimate. Mon to Sat, 8AM to 5PM, emergency 24/7.
Call (608) 909-9109Q.01 How much does a roof replacement cost in Madison?+
Q.02 How long does a replacement take?+
Q.03 Do I need a permit?+
Q.04 Should I replace or repair?+
Q.05 Can I replace my roof in winter?+
Q.06 Do you replace the decking?+
Q.07 Does Buckshot work with my insurance?+
Ready for a Roof That's Done Right?
Free inspection, written line-item estimate, GAF Master Elite installation, and a 50-year warranty. Most homes finished in a day. Family-owned since 1979.
Buckshot General Contracting · 621 N Sherman Ave, Suite B5, Madison, WI 53704 · (608) 909-9109 · WI License DC-080900045 · GAF Master Elite, FORTIFIED, BBB A+ · Mon to Sat 8AM to 5PM, emergency 24/7
Pricing ranges are typical estimates for the Madison area and are not a quote; your written estimate follows a free on-site measurement. Warranty terms are provided in writing with your estimate. Insurance coverage and outcomes vary by policy and carrier; the Sun Prairie claim describes one past result and is not a guarantee.